The Radical DSA and the New York City Mayor's Race

Properties1
tagsthird-way, dsa, mamdani, platform, counter-offensive

5 min read

The Radical DSA and the New York City Mayor’s Race

URL: https://www.thirdway.org/memo/the-radical-dsa-and-the-new-york-city-mayors-race Date: 2025-06-20 (published days before the NYC Democratic mayoral primary) | Outlet: third-way | Lean: center | Genre: primary-document

Summary

The origin document of the establishment’s anti-DSA case, published a year before the $15M program. Third Way’s method here is the one it has used ever since: do not argue with the candidate, quote the organization’s platform. The memo explicitly declines to take a position on whom New Yorkers should vote for, then attacks zohran-mamdani entirely through his dsa membership and the DSA national platform’s written planks.

This matters for the wiki’s central contested question. The memo is the clearest statement of the establishment’s theory of the case: that the DSA’s program, not its candidates’ campaign messaging, is the real object — and that a DSA politician running on rent freezes and buses inherits an organizational platform calling for nationalization, prison abolition, and NATO withdrawal. The DSA’s own convention record (metro-detroit-dsa-2025-convention-results, redstar-2024-communists-belong-in-dsa) is the material against which this claim should be checked; it is not simply a fabrication, which is what makes it the establishment’s most durable attack.

Third Way’s second claim is the downballot one: a Mamdani win is a national liability regardless of how he governs, because it supplies Republican ad copy in swing districts. This is the argument the promise-to-america-2026-pledge signatories — mostly frontliners and challengers — later acted on.

Key Claims / Facts

Nine DSA platform planks the memo cites as disqualifying:

  1. Policing: “defund the police” with budgets cut “towards zero,” decertify police unions, disarm officers, free all prisoners
  2. Social provision: universal free housing with rent control; guaranteed free water, energy, food, and college
  3. Economy: nationalize major industries, banks, insurance, real estate, telecom
  4. Health care: eliminate private health care via public ownership of hospitals and pharmaceutical production
  5. Labor: 32-hour work week with guaranteed union wages for all workers
  6. Energy: eliminate all fossil fuel use, ban new projects
  7. Military/foreign policy: drastically cut military spending, close foreign bases, withdraw from NATO
  8. Immigration: end deportations, abolish ICE, demilitarize the border
  9. Governance: abolish the Senate, extend voting to non-citizens, call a constitutional convention

Framing claims:

  • Third Way states it takes no position on the nomination itself; the objection is affiliation-based.
  • The planks are characterized not as a leftward shift but as a wholesale reordering of American society.
  • The stated national stakes: a Mamdani win would be “a devastating blow in the fight to defeat Trumpism” and would hand Republicans ready-made attack ads in swing districts.

Quotes

“While we take no position on who Democrats should vote for, we are deeply alarmed by one of the leading candidates: Zohran Mamdani.” — Third Way, “The Radical DSA and the New York City Mayor’s Race,” 2025-06-20

“it is his proud affiliation with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) that worries us most.” — Third Way, same memo

“Even a casual glance reveals ideas so extreme, so profoundly anathema to the vast majority of voters, that they sound like they were cooked up in the offices of a Trump-aligned ad maker.” — Third Way, same memo

“These are not policies that would move the country a few clicks to the left or shift the ‘Overton Window.’ Rather, they are a call to completely reorder American society in ways that are self-evidently bizarre, dangerous, and deeply unwise.” — Third Way, same memo

“Republican attack ads in swing districts attaching moderate Democratic candidates to Mamdani and the DSA practically write themselves.” — Third Way, same memo

Entities Mentioned

third-way, dsa, zohran-mamdani, democratic-party

Notes

Verification status of the nine planks: these are Third Way’s characterizations of DSA platform language, not verbatim platform text. The wiki does not yet hold the DSA national platform as a source — that is the single highest-value remaining ingest for adjudicating this memo. Several planks are consistent with DSA convention material already in the corpus (nationalization/decommodification, see decommodification); the “free all prisoners” and “abolish the Senate” characterizations in particular should be checked against actual platform wording before any blog use.

The affiliation-vs-agenda gap is the memo’s own vulnerability and worth noting for debate pages: Mamdani campaigned on fare-free buses, a rent freeze (rent-freeze), and city-run groceries (2026-mamdani-municipal-grocery-stores) — none of which appear among the nine planks. The memo’s answer is that platform, not campaign, reveals intent; the DSA-side answer is that the platform is aspirational and municipal governance is the actual record.

Date correction to expectations: this memo is from June 2025, a year earlier than the 2026 counter-offensive. It establishes that the establishment’s anti-DSA case predates the electoral losses that are usually given as its cause — useful against the narrative that Third Way only reacted after 2026 primary defeats.

Lean: center. No individual author byline; published under the organization.

Events: 2025-nyc-mayoral-general, 2026-establishment-counteroffensive Debates: is-the-dsa-taking-over-the-democratic-party, is-democratic-socialism-different-from-socialism, does-socialism-win-elections Entities: third-way, zohran-mamdani, dsa